The ever-increasing influence of… well… influencers

With Great Power Comes Great Un-Responsibility

What’s got us talking this month? The ever-increasing influence of… well… influencers! In our industry, influencers are garnering more power than ever before. Views, likes, clicks, tags and essentially AUDIENCES are increasing at an exciting but also scarily rapid rate.

In our ‘Under the Influence’ Perspective a few months ago we explained the many merits of utilising influencers for brands… however there are always sides to every story… We all know that the honest, uncensored rawness of the influencer – this new type of celebrity – is what makes them popular, but this rawness can also be uncalibrated and even dangerous. In this month’s WING Perspective we ask the question… ARE INFLUENCERS OUT OF CONTROL?

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

But first a little WING round-up… April was a blimin’ beaut of a month. Chandon rolled out more of our colourful stop-motion films featuring Alonso and Vandoorne, Betfair released our crazy ‘Under The Spell’ film which we worked on with our friends at CAA Sports featuring Barcelona Football superstars and a hypnotist with a banging hairstyle. And McLaren premiered a beautiful piece that we are super proud of remembering the greatest lap of all time: ‘Legendary Laps Ayrton Senna at Donington ’93’. Give it a watch and If you aren’t hit in the feels like a ton of bricks, especially with the final moment, then you officially have no soul. We are also delighted to welcome Emma, our brand new Senior Creative to the WING family!

And now we step to it…

The Beginning

In the beginning, there was darkness… or in fact, more of a 56k dial-up modem connection and sites such as ebaumsworld.com (shudder). Then the world-changing monster that was YouTube arrived… then Twitter, and Instagram and so on and so forth.

Back in 2005, the public’s thirst for down to earth, relatable stars was already there, but it was mainly satisfied by reality TV. Even then it was clear that consumers were starting to trust ‘real’ people’s recommendations more than traditional celebrities. People felt that the traditional celebrities were selling a party line rather than giving a genuine seal of approval on products they loved. So much so that Jade Goody’s perfume was ACTUALLY outselling David Beckham’s! She even became Heat Magazine’s biggest selling cover star ever.

Even though this was a very specific type of celebrity, the Jades from the Bermondsey block were already becoming as influential as the Angelinas from the Beverly Hills Boulevard. And their endorsements were a lot cheaper to afford too.

In the years leading up to 2005, people also found themselves becoming the first viral home-movie stars. They would post random videos online and see where they went. You may remember some of the most famous pre-YouTube viral hits like ‘Star Wars Kid’, ‘Numa Numa Guy’ and the musical piece of Bach-esque genius known as… ‘PEANUT BUTTER JELLY TIME’.

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.
For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

The combination of this relatively new phenomenon to ‘go viral’, mixed with a clear appetite for authentic celebrity and the new king of video-sharing, YouTube, brought about the perfect storm within which the ‘Influencer’ was born.

Back at the beginning, reaching the front page of YouTube was essentially your online career catalyst. Much like a musician’s ‘difficult second album’ or a feature filmmaker’s high stakes ‘sophomore release’, the challenge once you had your online hit, was to work out a formula of increasing, maintaining and then continuing to build your audience. The formula was cracked and as they say, the rest is history. Experts in the areas of culture, comedy, fashion, gaming and fitness started appearing more and more frequently, generating hundreds of millions of £’s not only for themselves but for the brands that backed them. As with any new industry, there is a certain level of discovery and risk-taking. However, the new-found power of these non-media-trained ‘celebrities’ has now become a serious cause for concern.

Love me, love me, say that you love me?

As with our industry, one must find new ways to gain more attention, and this case, clicks. Although it is easier than ever to spread your YouTube, Instagram, and Twitter influence, it is harder than ever to stay at the front of the pack. This can lead to influencers going to misguided or even desperate measures to succeed.

YouTuber Logan Paul, one of the biggest and fasting growing social media stars in the world, made a name for himself for his extreme pranks and memes (viewer discretion advised). As he became more popular the ambition of his videos increased; however, he has always maintained a level of irreverence, building a brand called Maverick, centred around the philosophy of its namesake.

On 31 December he uploaded a film titled ‘‘We found a dead body in a Japanese Suicide forest.’

At the beginning of the film, he excitedly states that ‘This marks a moment in YouTube history. This has never hopefully happened to anyone on YouTube ever. Pucker the f**k up, because you’re never going to see a video like this again.’ He and his friends spend the day in Japan, pranking locals and heading into the infamous suicide forest in Aokigahara where it has been said that 100 people a year commit suicide.

In the film, he shows a body hanging lifeless from a tree. He blurs out the face but every other part of the person’s body is in focus. We see Paul’s shock when he initially sees the body, however, he and his friends move closer, commenting and even making jokes whilst standing right next to them.

At times during and at the end of the film, he states that he wants to bring awareness to mental health and suicide and gives out the details of charities, clearly believing that this would justify his horrific prior actions.

There was eventually a huge backlash to the video which was taken down the next day. Both Paul and YouTube came of it terribly, and rightly so. Paul sent out two apologies, one written statement including his understanding that ‘with great power comes great responsibility’ and also a seemingly heartfelt video claiming that those who are defending him need to stop and that he made a huge mistake.

The problem was, even Paul’s apology was seen by many including Game of Thrones’ Sophie Turner to be ‘self-praising’.

The most troubling thing to come out of the whole affair was that it had amassed 6 million views and thousands of likes before he took the video down. Meaning that a huge amount of people thought that this was OK. Many of his fans actually defended him so much that they verbally attacked his critics. This is one of the most high-profile influencer controversies, but there are many, many more.

Pew Die Pie – the first YouTube star to reach 50 million subscribers and daubed King of YouTube earns £12million a year from revenue. This guy has some serious influence… and some seriously bad judgement. He was dropped by Disney for videos featuring anti-Semitic jokes and Nazi imagery, including two men holding a ‘Death to All Jews’ sign. He’s also used the N-word to ‘jokingly’ let out his frustration during a video game, later stating ‘I didn’t mean it in a bad way’.

Michael and Heather Martin were charged with neglect and emotional and physical abuse of their kids, as they used their channel DaddyOFive to gain more and more ‘comedy’ clicks. The Australia-based Jalal brothers were charged with a public nuisance order after creating a series of tasteless videos including fake drive-by shootings and suicide bomb stunts. – the list goes on and on.

It also spreads into Instagram, and the Twittersphere too – online star Belle Gibson was famed because she apparently beat her terminal cancer diagnosis through healthy eating. It turns out the diagnosis was a lie and she allegedly failed to give a substantial amount of revenue to cancer charities as was promised. The 26-year-old gave a strange excuse admitting : “None of it is true…I am still jumping between what I think I know and what is reality. I have lived it and I’m not really there yet.”

WINGpinion

Whether or not you have a narcissistic bone in your body, you need to have a certain amount of confidence to not only become an influencer, but to become a successful one.

As we know from history, the formula of confidence + determination + power can = a hugely positive, but also devastatingly negative effect. Take Logan Paul. Clearly not all of his fans felt the need to defend his actions but many did. When you have such fanatic subscribers that believe even something as awful as this is totally OK, then you can understand how creators such as Paul are emboldened and possibly even out of control.

On top of this, they have a responsibility to their fans. They need to deliver what people like about their early videos, but they also need to keep their output fresh and get people talking. If your genre is comedic or prank based especially, then in their mind they have an obligation to push boundaries. Herein lies the problem however, because they also have a social and moral responsibility too. And sometimes the two don’t mix.

Popular wholesome YouTube stars The Eh Bee Family hit the nail on the head in their video ‘Dear Logan Paul’. They state that YouTubers clearly need to stand out and there’s nothing wrong with that. You NEED to be over the top. But as they say: ‘there is a difference between going over the top and crossing the line’.

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

Yes, some influencers are clearly out of control – but to be fair, this is what’s happening both in the online and actual world. The world is becoming more and more extreme and knowing this, we shouldn’t be surprised when lines are crossed BUT we should all be very vocal in shutting down videos or posts that cross that said line. It’s difficult because the line of what is and isn’t acceptable is being blurred more and more by celebrities and politicians, but through conversation and debate we can not only define the line, but make sure we limit the influencers that are totally out of control to a minimum. An absolute minimum.

WINGers Top Three Pieces of Content

The Future of Sport Analysis: This clip blew our minds! It’s simply a showcase of a basketball pundit analysing a game but…you’ve never seen it this before before. This is the the future of sport analysis!

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

We love this piece of content for ASOS by Raine Allen-Miller. It’s bold, striking but most of all; simple.

And finally, ‘Welcome Home’ by Apple (introducing the Home Pod) has divided the office.

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

Some of us are loving the mix of Spike Jonze, FKA Twigs and Jamiroqui-esque vibes, others see it as a bit of a rip off of Sia’s Chandelier music video. What do you think?

[disqus-inserter]

WINGstagram

[instagram-feed]

Recent Tweets