Which Side Are You On

Celebrities vs Influencers

‘Summer-summer-summer-time… Time to sit back and unwind…’ whilst reading our latest WING Perspective… This month has been HOT, but we’ve luckily been working on some very cool projects.

We’ve been shooting at McLaren and then at Shepperton for Jaguar with our pals at CAA, then up in Newcastle for PING, further north in Scotland for Aberdeen Standard Investments and further afield in Barcelona working with Sidhu & Simon for Tata Communications, Mercedes and Formula One.

WING June

While all this of was going on, McLaren and Ultimate Ears released our body-popping film celebrating the launch of the MEGABOOM MCL33. McLaren and Codemasters also released ‘The Greatest Lap You’ve Never Seen’, a computer-generated recreation of Ayrton Senna’s 1988 pole lap at Monaco which was famously never captured by cameras. This was a bit of a dream come true as we had the pleasure and privilege of working with the legend that is Murray Walker on creating the commentary. At 94, we must say he’s still got it!

But let’s get down to it… this month we look at one of the juiciest battles taking place in our industry right now. The Players? Traditional Celebrities vs Influencers. The Battleground? Our hearts and minds… and devices. Ali v Foreman ain’t got nothing on this…

Influence Me!

Right. We know what you’re thinking; ‘Influencers have it on lock. They’re not only a huge part of the marketing zeitgeist but they’re captaining the blimmin’ ship!’. You may very well be right (you’ll have to read on to find out if you are though!). It’s a fashionable opinion but is this actually the case?

Well, let’s look at the fundamentals. Influencers are increasingly behaving like celebrities. No doubt about it. They are releasing product ranges, autobiographies (here’s looking at you Zoella and Jim Chapman) and some are even unable to walk down the street without being accosted. They are becoming so popular that many are now undoubtedly holding more sway than celebrities and some are even earning more cash.

On the other side of the coin, traditional celebrities are sidelining their publicists and now using more direct forms of marketing through their own social media accounts, taking their perfectly formed faces away from billboards and onto our devices and online platforms.

As the landscape of ‘figurehead-led’ marketing (it’s got a ring to it) is clearly changing and the lines are being blurred, there is a need to re-define the differences between these two ‘opponents’. According to Lucy Hitz, Head of Marketing Communications at Simply Measured, influencers tend to be: “1. A subject matter expert. 2. Self-built 3. Famous on the internet first. 4. Credible and 5. Well known.” Fair? We think so. She defines celebrities as:

“Primarily valued for level of exposure he or she can provide, not necessarily tied to knowledge base or credibility. Made famous through more traditional channels (TV, Radio, etc.). Not necessarily running their own social accounts: The brand partners with the personality, not the creativity or content creation”.

Marylin Monroe

Again, fair and careful not to denigrate celebrities with the ingenious use of the word ‘necessarily’ (which might just be an addition to the ‘legally covering my ass’ stakes!).

But what about actual influence? What do they both bring to the table?

Senior Communications Manager at Microsoft (Ron Schott) explains the main difference as being: “a question of mass reach versus mass impact. Influencers carry weight in subjects. Celebs bring exposure”.

Hmm…there’s a pattern forming here. Actually, more than that…a perfectly baked influence cake. The main ingredient? TRUST. In a 2016 joint study by Twitter and facial recognition experts Annalect show that the stats back this up – “40% of respondents said they’ve purchased an item online after seeing it used by an influencer on Instagram, Twitter, Vine or YouTube. Also, 20% of respondents said they shared something they saw from an influencer, while one-third of millennials say they follow a creator on Twitter or Vine”. Why wouldn’t we trust influencers? After all, they’re ‘real’, ‘credible’ and ‘trustworthy’. How can a celebrity, who most likely lives a very different lifestyle to me, really know what’s best for me when I have a ‘friend’ to advise what to buy instead?

This is the mindset many influencer followers have but what if this trust starts to disappear? In a 2017 survey by DealSpotr, they found that although influencers are still very much on the upswing, the level of trust is now in fact potentially starting to fade. The report’s standout finding was that “a slight majority (52%) of Millennials said they trust influencers less than they used to”. Meaning that maybe, just maybe, influencer trust has peaked?

A Pinch of Salt

ChesterfieldWhatever the answer, we do seem to take influencer’s endorsements more seriously than celebrities. Why? Well, influencers have only recently come into existence. Therefore on the whole, despite a few bad apples (which we looked at in our last blog post) most haven’t had time to really have their reputations tainted yet.

Celebrities have been telling us what to look to like, what to smell like and where to buy our groceries since the dawn of advertising. We know the deal and have done for a long time. ‘They get paid to recommend something they might genuinely recommend. But even if they don’t, it’s OK. They’re celebrities, it’s what they do’.

Do Anthony Joshua and Neymar really think Beats by Dre are the best headphones around? Who knows? They might prefer Sennheiser or Bose but they are paid to endorse Beats. Ultimately we know this but the key factor is that we are willing to take celebrity endorsements with a pinch of salt. We are not willing to do the same with influencers yet. We don’t yet allow the same suspension of disbelief for influencers….when perhaps, we should. Once the likes of Zoella or Pew Di Pie reached a certain level of fame, they became just as susceptible to the payday game (Zoella’s advent calendar anyone?)…

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

In fact, aren’t influencers more susceptible to selling their ‘souls’ and promoting something they don’t necessarily believe in because, after all, most haven’t earned their millions like the more traditional celebrities have? (Or more importantly, when does an influencer actually cross the divide to celebrity? Maybe that’s for another time?!)

Still think influencers win? Or have we evened the playing field a bit?

Influencers may have more trust, but do they have the right audiences to claim a flawless victory over celebrities? It is clear that the youth of today have a favourite. In fact, a whopping 70% of YouTube subscribers trust influencers more than traditional celebrities.

Creative Director of marketing and influencer agency REDPILL Liam Corrigan tells us: “13-17 and 18-24-year-olds are typically the major fan bases for the top 2% of YouTube influencers. They have a high emotional attachment to YouTubers because they have a close connection through social and are consistently watching more authentic, relatable content”.

On the other hand, they have less disposable income than other demographics but many have parents or guardians that can fill that gap for them. Influencers also relate strongly to 18-30s and the 30 plus but the balance of influence shifts back to the more traditional celebrities when you start to look into older demographics. Put it this way, your dad is more likely to have seen George Clooney endorse Nespresso than a Gary Vaynerchuk Instagram post about his favourite Californian red wine.

WINGpinion

Celebrities vs Influencers, in the ring…who wins?

It all depends on the audience you are trying to reach, how successful you are at it and ultimately what constitutes TRUE influence. Most celebs use Twitter or Instagram rather than Facebook and Youtube, which is interesting because Twitter’s numbers are dwindling. Twitter’s 300million and Instagram’s 800million users are dwarfed in comparison to Youtube (1.5bn) and Facebook’s (2bn). Online and in terms of trust, it looks like influencers do indeed smash celebrities out of the park.

Aha! But what about the more traditional advertising platforms? What about advertising mecca The Super Bowl? Well to be fair, despite Doritos having traditionally championed non-celebs with their UGC commercials, most popular Super Bowl ads will pay big bucks for a recognisable celebrity face…and Doritos have gone back to this over the last couple of years. The Super Bowl has traditionally attracted big numbers but this year’s audience numbers slipped to 103.4 million.

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

Liam explains: “Although the Super Bowl is a special kind of beast where celebrities are still winning…most brands don’t have that kind of budget. Influencer engagement rates are much higher for the money the majority of brands want to spend. Costs per engagements? Hands down influencers always win. They’ve worked hard for their channels, to grow that fan base and produce content that their audiences not only like but love.”

And finally….to set the argument to rest, let’s take a look at the KSI charity boxing match with Joe Weller which took place in Feb 2018. The event had 1 million concurrent viewers on a YouTube live stream.

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

Merge the influencer’s channels together and you get 20 million joint views. The real stat that blows the celebrity argument out of the water is the fact that this event had 300million extended reach views where influencers and fans were sharing and then sharing and then sharing again.

This is for two only recently known YouTubers boxing each other… and it was bigger than Mayweather vs McGregor. A fight that boxing billed as one of the biggest matches of all time. Yep. You can check the numbers. It’s nuts!

So there you have it. Influencers are your clear winners, but it is not the perfect victory you may have assumed. There are still certain areas where celebrities are holding onto their dominance. But now is most definitely the time of the influencer. Will they continue their growth? Or will the bubble burst?

Well. the one thing that will halt the emergence of influencers is when they lose the trust of their audience. How does this happen you may ask? You’ll have to find out in our next WING Perspective where we look into Influencer and Celebrity wins and fails. Stay tuned for some absolute CORKERS!

WINGers Top Three Pieces of Content

WINGers TOP THREE PIECES OF CONTENT

We LOVE this homage to Hip Hop by director Robbie Samuels. It’s original, funny and funky fresh.

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

The World Cup launch trailer for the BBC has caused some debate in the office. Is it clever and lovely? or totally ridiculous and OTT? We can’t quite decide but would love to hear your thoughts.

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded.

And finally, this slightly terrifying but utterly original piece for Pilgrim’s Choice directed by Joseph Mann utilises CGI and puppetry to visualise a real cheese lover’s insane dream. Warning, don’t eat cheese before bed!…or maybe do, if you enjoy dreams as crazy as this!

[disqus-inserter]

WINGstagram

[instagram-feed]

Recent Tweets