The Christmas Adverts Lowdown
Christmas is the BIG GAME.
For our industry, Christmas is the BIG GAME. Here in the UK, this is our Super Bowl and boy do we know it. These are the campaigns where agencies and brands start planning from…pretty much now, and spend big in the hope that their messages can strike a chord with millions of consumers.
This year £6billion was spent on Christmas Advertising. £6BILLION… Imagine the Bitcoinage on that!!! (or not!)
John Lewis, Aldi and Sainsbury’s all spent a reported £7million each on their 2017 Christmas Advertising Campaigns.
This might sound like a lot, but when you look at the almost guaranteed ROI that these brands have been experiencing as a result then it makes total sense. Christmas has always been king, but ever since John Lewis released ‘The Long wait’ back in 2011, the game was changed forever. This was epic.
The Game Changer
This simple, yet beautiful story of a little boy impatiently counting down the days to Christmas, only for us to get to the big day and see that his excitement was not to receive but to give, hit us with a HUGE bang. FUN FACT, the boy has just played Orlando Bloom’s son in the latest Pirates of Caribbean! But we digress… the casting of an adorable kid, the cinematic visuals and stunning, stripped back cover of The Smith’s ‘Please, Please, Please, Let Me Get What I Want’ by Slow Moving Millie made for a magic combination. This (now classic) advert pulled on our collective heartstrings and had even the most stoic of us wailing like grown babies. As a direct result of that campaign, total sales were up 9.3% to £596 million in the five weeks to December 31st that year. This was especially significant because 2011 saw a depressing trend in the high street. On top of the in-store success for John Lewis, online revenue rose by an incredible 28%.
As Peter Parker’s Aunt May once said, “with great power comes great responsibility”… well, in this case, the newfound power of the John Lewis marketing team came with a huge responsibility… to deliver. And deliver they did. Since this game-changer, they have capitalised on its success in almost auteur-like fashion each year, ensuring an unmissable aesthetic and narrative that is sure to hit you right in the feels.
But all good things must come to an end and there are hints that John Lewis is going to need to switch things up. After 2016’s ‘Buster the Boxer’ release, John Lewis’s Sir Charlie Mayfield said ‘Is it as ground-breaking as the first time we did it or people saw it? Possibly not”. This year’s ‘Moz The Monster’ sparked many a debate in local pubs as to whether John Lewis had lost their mojo… Calls around WING of ‘it’s the same as the penguin one!’ and ‘it doesn’t really actually make sense’ were certainly heard.
But it did make most of us at least smile. Which is a good thing! Either way, with each year they manage to achieve a level of public anticipation and goodwill that even the most popular film studios can only dream of. However, are we headed downhill a bit? Do we need to pull up our creative socks and also resist a bit of the sanitization and obsessive safety now required from most brands? Academy films Simon Cooper seems to think so: ‘Not our finest year, I think it is safe to say, with the heady whiff of client fear a rather-too-frequent ingredient. Fear of quotas, fear of not appealing to as wide an audience as possible, even if it means appealing less overall. Fear of being anything other than safe’.
So, clearly over the last 7 years, brands have had to up their game (The Sainsbury’s ‘1914’ ad from 2014 is one of the best EVER) by making some of their most heart-warming and ambitious content EVER. As The Drum’s Brian Cooper says, ‘Christmas ads are now considered cultural events – milestones, even – rather than just 30-second selling spots.’ But from the millions spent, only a fraction will, of course, be spent on the production of the commercials themselves (this fraction being around the £1million mark for John Lewis’s output). The majority of the budget will be spent on seeding it out into both the actual and virtual ether.
Who Won?
Who came out on top in the race to become the champion? What about that all-important ROI?
We’ve looked at a combination of responses from facial recognition data, social media, and the latest sales figures (from Realeyes, 4C, Brand 3 and Kantar World Panel) to find out who the real winners and losers were at Christmas.
According to data from Realeyes (where they measure the emotional reactions to 55 of the biggest Christmas ads from over of 3,300 people), John Lewis’s Moz the Monster didn’t even make the top 10 (they came 17th!). Especially interesting considering Buster the Boxer came 1st just one year earlier.
Campaign Live reports that John Lewis only received 74,039 engagements within 12 hours and completely mixed reviews. A disaster for them! Tesco’s sales rose by a BEAUT 3.1% in the 12 weeks to 31 December (far above their competitors, Sainsbury’s, Asda and Morrisons – who came in at around 2% each) and they scored high in the social and emotional engagement stats.
Aldi’s ‘Kevin the Carrot’ was hugely popular all round as was The BBC’s ‘The Supporting Act’ which generated almost 1 million views within two hours of release to hugely positive reviews.
Sales wise, big hitter John Lewis ‘hit big’ again. But for a large part of the population, there was much left to be desired by this year’s ad, especially on an emotional level. Maybe it was the fact that the general public feels it’s time to start doing things differently. Let’s face it: boxer, bear, snow-couple (yeah that’s a ‘thing’), penguin and monster. When you look at it like that it all feels rather anthropomorphically formulaic (try saying that three times in a row quickly!). What was originally ‘touching’, ‘beautiful’ and ‘sweet’ content seems to have ventured into the ‘worthy’ and ‘expected’. We can, therefore, confirm that: John Lewis are… NO LONGER THE CHAMPIONS OF CHRISTMAS!!!!
Judging from the research (that we find important, anyway) in terms of the big brands….it is a TIE between TESCO’s ‘EVERYONE’S WELCOME’ and THE BBC’s ‘THE SUPPORTING ACT’! Yep. With Tesco, not only are their sales figures, social and emotional engagement outstanding but they seem to have totally nailed the more down to earth, realism that many other brands have been trying to conquer for years. Their lovely, honest piece is a beautiful work that taps into everyone’s personal traditions and the essence of a genuine British family Christmas. Although Tesco had their critics from many sides – from supposed ‘tick box’ diversity (the advert featured a range of minorities and non-christian characters) to the fact that Tesco doesn’t actually sell Halal turkey whilst promising ‘Turkey, Every Which Way’ – despite this, to us, the advert simply sums up Christmas in Britain and boy do they do it well.
The same can be said of the BBC. The BBC took many by surprise with just how lovely and effective their ad was. In terms of Christmas advertising, they haven’t been spoken about in the same breath as John Lewis for years, let alone come out on top. With zero dialogue and the latest Stop Motion techniques, their story of a dancing dad and daughter was absolutely stunning. Like Tesco, the film had criticisms – mainly from the lack of a Christian presence. But there was an overwhelming response from the majority of the public and both adverts mark a new era in Christmas advertising, one where John Lewis is no longer at the top of the pile. So, there we have it. We have new champs!…can they repeat their success in 2018? Will John Lewis pull off a comeback? We shall see.
WINGpinion – Our Top 3
We’ve been debating since Christmas and have finally whittled down our own favourite Christmas Ads, irrespective of anything other than what we think is brilliant.
3. ‘Monster Discounts – Parody’
By FRANK PR and The School of Communication Arts. This parody of John Lewis’s Moz advert is awesome. Michel Gondry perfected how to ‘Swede’ films and it’s only right that people do the same for his own work.
2. BBC ‘The Supporting Act’ by BBC CREATIVE
Yep. What stood out for us is the way in which they actually managed to tell an old message (stop working and focus on those who are most important) in a new way. It’s fresh, it’s exciting and damn sweet.
1. ‘Christmas 2017’ – Edeka by Jung Von Matt
We LOVE the ambition and classy use of CGI mixed with live action. The gingerbread heart moment was lovely but to be honest….the ad had us at ‘lonely German robot’.

